For agtech companies

Will they actually adopt it?

You can build something that works and still watch it sit unused.

Adoption isn't a product problem. It's a question about how growers decide, who they trust, when in the season they'll even look at it, and whether the thing can physically be sold, delivered and serviced where you're selling it. I answer that before you've spent the money finding out.

Tell me what you're building
The problem

Every plan rests on an assumption about the farmer. Almost nobody checks it.

The product was validated with people who already liked it. The pricing was set against competitors rather than against what a grower gives up to buy it. The route to market is a slide that says "distribution partnerships."

None of that is incompetence — it's the normal condition of a company that has been heads-down building. But it means the riskiest number in the plan is the one nobody has tested: that a farmer, in season, with their own money, will change what they already do.

What a wrong answer costs

The cheapest thing in the plan to check. The most expensive to get wrong.

A country manager is a full salary package, months to hire and longer to ramp — committed before you know whether the market wants the product.

A launch that doesn't land burns a year of runway, and the credibility of your next raise with it.

A distribution agreement signed with the wrong partner can lock up a territory for years, and you'll be the one who has to unpick it.

Every one of those decisions is made on an assumption about the farmer.

What I do

Reality Check

A fixed-scope review of whether this lands — and what to change before it doesn't.

What I look at

Send me the deck, the plan, the pricing, and whatever market evidence you have.

  • Whether growers will adopt it — measured against how they actually make decisions, not how the deck assumes they do.
  • Whether your positioning survives contact with a grower and the agronomist they trust.
  • Route to market — how it gets sold, delivered and serviced here, who needs to be paid along the way, and whether the margin survives it.
  • Where it lands in the season, and what that does to your pipeline and your cash.
  • What the local competition actually is — which is usually "what they already do", not another company.
  • What to fix before launch, in priority order, with the reasoning attached.
Start with a Reality Check
1
Reality Check

The diagnosis above, as a fixed-scope engagement.

2
Go-to-Market Build

We fix what it surfaced — positioning, route to market, and messaging that lands with growers and the agronomists they trust.

3
In Your Corner

Fractional and ongoing. I stay the grower gut-check on every big call as you launch and scale.

Your alternatives

You have five options. I'm one of them.

You're already comparing me to these. Here they are honestly, including where I'm the wrong answer.

OptionRoughly what it costsHow longThe catch
Hire a country managerA full packageMonths to hire, longer to rampYou're committing to the market before you know it wants you
A large consultancySignificantTwo to three monthsGood process, strong decks, no paddock
Ask your distributorFreeImmediateThey're paid to tell you it'll sell
Ask your investorsFreeImmediateThey don't know either — and now they know you don't
Launch and find outA year of runwayYou'll know in 18 monthsThe most expensive option, usually chosen by default
Selsmeyer & CoA fixed fee, agreed up frontWeeksBoutique by design — senior attention on your decision, not a bench of juniors. A check on the plan, not a team to hand delivery to.

And no agenda. I don’t sell equipment, take commissions, or have a product waiting at the end of the review. The only thing I’m selling is the answer — which is why it’s sometimes “don’t.”

Cost and timing vary by market and stage — these are shapes, not quotes.

Fit

Who this is for — and who it isn't.

This is for you if

  • You've got a product that works and traction somewhere, and you're bringing it into Australia or New Zealand
  • You're already here and adoption is slower than the plan said it would be
  • You're about to commit to a distribution or dealer agreement
  • An investor asked whether farmers will actually adopt it and you didn't love your own answer
  • You're still deciding whether to build for this market at all — and you'd rather find out now than after the launch

This isn't for you if

  • There's nothing concrete to test yet. Pre-product is fine — early is often the best time. But I need something written down: a product definition, a business case, a plan. I can't pressure-test an idea that hasn't been thought through.
  • The decision is already locked. I'll tell you what I see either way. But if nothing can change, you're buying a second opinion you can't act on.
  • You want someone to run it, not check it. I'll tell you what to do and why — executing it week to week is a different engagement, and worth talking about separately.
  • Price is the deciding factor. Doing nothing is always cheaper. What you're paying for is specific knowledge of the market you're about to walk into.
How it works

Four steps, and only one of them is a meeting.

1
You send what you've got

The deck, the plan, the pricing, the market evidence. However rough.

2
We agree the scope and the fee

Fixed, up front, in writing. No hourly billing and no scope creep.

3
I check it against reality

Growers, agronomists, dealers, the channel — the people who decide whether this sells.

4
You get it back in writing

What holds, what doesn't, and what to do about it. One call if you want it.

Proof of concept

He didn't proceed.

A grower in Western Australia was about to commit capital to a biochar system. He had the vendor's quote and the business case in hand. I went through it from his side of the table — what the modelling assumed, what it left out, what it meant for his carbon position.

The numbers didn't work over the payback period, and the reasons were sitting in what the vendor hadn't concluded.

That's the same analysis, pointed the other way. When I tell you whether growers will adopt your product, this is the seat I'm doing it from.

Engaged by two businesses. $11,000.

See if it's a fit

Tell me what you're building.

A few lines is plenty. I'll tell you honestly whether I can help — and if I can't, I'll usually know who can.

I read everything myself. You’ll hear back within two business days.